429 Magazine

Supreme Court Justice defends anti-LGBT remarks

By Anna Peirano

Yesterday, during a discussion at Princeton University, Justice Antonin Scalia of the Supreme Court defended remarks he'd previously made about his anti-LGBT views. 

The Supreme Court will hear arguments on both DOMA and Prop 8 in the coming months, and make a landmark decision one way or another that could drastically shift the tide of equality in the United States. 

Scalia fielded a question from a student asking about his previous remarks comparing anti-equality laws to laws that ban things like bestiality and murder. 

The judge said that legislative bodies can discriminate against LGBT people if they find them to be "immoral." He said, "If we cannot have moral feelings against homosexuality, can we have it against murder? Can we have it against other things?"

Scalia also said that the Constitution was not a document meant to be a framework for protecting the rights of all Americans. He said, "It isn't a living document. It's dead, dead, dead, dead."

The Supreme Court is expected to make their decision regarding both DOMA and Prop 8 by June of 2013. 

Written By:
Anna Peirano
Anna Peirano
Tue, Dec 11, 2012
Comments
Comment by Bill Oderkirk
over 3 years ago

So we can assume Scalia doesn't believe in evolution - of homo sapien, of democracy?

Comment by Matthew Wexler
over 3 years ago

A supreme court justice comparing homosexuality to murder under the guise of "morality". What a complete shit show.

over 3 years ago

There is an expression that goes like this: You can't reason someone out of something that he/she hasn't been reasoned into. If only Scalia could be impeached, or replaced because of his egregious interpretation of our Constitution. Perhaps we should pray for him.

Comment by Larry Martin
over 3 years ago

Sounds like he should also recuse himself of ruling on this matter also.

over 3 years ago

the man and his principles: nefarious.

Comment by Bruce Davidson
over 3 years ago

As usual, the view from the Great White North is confused. Many Canadians admire the U.S. constitution precisely because it seems to be a living document, and not "dead, dead, dead, dead" as Justice Scalia says. For more than two centuries it has been interpreted and re-interpreted by all three branches of government to adapt to the changing times. Justice Scalia appears to be stuck in some kind of time-warp, in which whatever was "true" a hundred years ago, or two hundred years ago, remains immutably "true" today. I hope that when he comes to consider DOMA and Prop 8 he will remember that he has sworn to uphold the constitution, even if doing so means that he must set his own so-called "moral" views aside.

Comment by lauura
10 months ago

You can't reason someone out of something that he/she hasn't been reasoned into. watch Hotel Transylvania 2 online watch The Peanuts Movie online watch Crimson Peak online watch Rings online watch The Outskirts online watch The Peanuts Movie online watch Everest online watch Masterminds online watch Transporter Refueled online watch The Intern online watch The Visit online watch Legend online watch Bridge of Spies online watch The Outskirts online watch The Intern online watch Pan online watch Spectre online Watch In the Heart of the Sea Online watch Maze Runner 2 The Scorch Trials online watch Hotel Transylvania 2 online watch Bridge of Spies online watch Goosebumps online Watch Alvin and the Chipmunks 4 The Road Chip Online watch Crimson Peak online Watch Sisters Online watch Transporter Refueled online watch War Room online watch Transporter Refueled online watch Victor Frankenstein online Watch Steve Jobs Online watch By The Sea online watch The Walk online Watch In the Heart of the Sea Online Watch Alvin and the Chipmunks 4 The Road Chip Online watch The Intern online Watch Star Wars 7 The Force Awakens Online watch Hotel Transylvania 2 online watch Crimson Peak online watch The Visit online watch The Martian online watch By The Sea online watch Goosebumps online watch Hotel Transylvania 2 online watch Masterminds online watch The Walk online watch Pan online Watch Star Wars 7 The Force Awakens Online watch Bridge of Spies online watch Rings online watch The Good Dinosaur online

Comment by fashion1
7 months ago

Now, regardless of whether you are a "strap person" or "bracelet person," both options have their advantages and disadvantages: the rolex replica deeper you dive, the more pressure your body and suit will experience. Which basically means that a neoprene suit that starts out being very tight suddenly becomes loose - and with it, your dive watch. An replica watches uk easily adjustable clasp extension, such as that offered with the Seiko Marinemaster, or the rather complex clasp of the breitling replica Sea-Dweller Deepsea could be the answer to that problem, but I have rarely witnessed a swiss replica watches diver constantly adjusting his or her watch manually when diving.

Politics
Chillary: The Absolute Best of Clinton 2016 Swag
Politics
When Audra McDonald Claps Back, All the World Hears
open at work
Lauren Conrad is About to Bust "The Hills" Wide Open
Poll_balloon
Do you own your own business?
 
Yes
 
No
 
Trying to