Magazine_logo_black
 
Large_left_arrow Large_right_arrow

ENDA, We Hardly Know Ya

ENDA, or the Employment Non-Discrimination Act, was recently reintroduced in both the US Senate and the House of Representatives. The legislation, which would prohibit discrimination in hiring and employment on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity, has been for years a contentious matter.

In 2007, the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) refused to support a transgender-inclusive ENDA and the resulting fall-out may well go down as the organization’s biggest public relations debacle.

The current version of ENDA has the full support of several trans-led organizations, including the National Center for Transgender Equality.

It’s widely held that this bill is both necessary and long overdue. On the face of it, ENDA would provide a way for people to fight back against discrimination, if they feel they were unfairly treated in the job selection process or unjustly fired.

But while ENDA seems like a good idea, there’s a danger of it being seen as the catch-all solution to discrimination against LGBTQ people. Indeed, with every passing year, ENDA becomes more of a Holy Grail, inducing more people to believe that the simple passage of this long-simmering bill will bring an end to discrimination against queer and trans people.

The fact, though, is that the support for ENDA will only mean a victory of sorts for people whom look for employment in workplaces of a certain size, those which hire at least 15 employers. ENDA doesn’t apply to religious organizations, and that clause has drawn criticism from many, including the ACLU and Lambda Legal.

Like other “progressive LGBT” endeavors, ENDA’s support also comes at the cost of re-affirming views about homosexuality as innate and beyond one’s control. For example, the American Psychological Association supports ENDA and notes that “psychologists do not consider sexual orientation for most people to be a conscious choice that can be voluntarily changed.”  

But as I’ve written elsewhere, this kind of adherence to the idea that sexuality is beyond our control and immutable is dangerous because, for one thing, it invites discrimination against those who believe otherwise and act accordingly.

While it’s true that gender identity has been included, we ought to be concerned that the bill still allows employers to dictate “dress or grooming standards.”  In effect, those transitioning need to conform to the expectations of their “intended gender.”

Where does that leave gender non-conforming people? And what does ENDA really do for people who may not even be hired in the first place simply because they don’t conform or pass according to our still outmoded ideas of gender?  

As it is, transgender people who don’t pass - because they lack the funds for expensive and multiple medical procedures or because they simply don’t want to - are easily discriminated against in matters like employment.

That discrimination can happen in ways that are completely indiscernible or difficult to prove. The fact that the legislation effectively writes in requirements to pass means that gender-non-conforming people are effectively written out of a public conversation about what it means to be LGBTQ. The fact that ENDA doesn't even apply to places that employ fewer than 15 employees removes oversight over smaller businesses.

ENDA is not entirely toothless. After all, we do have legislation in place to prohibit discrimination against women and other minorities, and there have been several instances of people gaining redress. But, as Liza Featherstone has pointed out in her reporting on the massive Walmart gender discrimination lawsuit, “ Change cannot come from the courtroom alone.”  

At best, ENDA has symbolic value, and I fully understand the value of symbols. But my concern here is that the passage of ENDA will allow too many to forget that LGBTQ people aren’t just fragile creatures "born this way" whose rights are limited to outmoded and dangerous ideas of what counts as acceptable behaviour and presentation. In addition, ENDA does nothing to address the systemic forms of economic discrimination which, in the long run, do more harm to larger populations.  It may even help to hide all that poverty and structural inequality by whitewashing labor relations in the US with a “LGBT victory”.

ENDA advocates are fond of repeating the same fact, that, “Yes, it's completely legal to fire or not hire someone for being gay in 29 states. If you're transgender, the number spikes to 34.” The implication here, of course, is that we should be horrified. Can you imagine! It’s legal to fire people for being gay or trans!

This conveniently ignores an issue that ENDA simply cannot address: in the US, employment is “at-will” in all states except Montana. This means that you can be fired for, well, no reason at all.

In other words, it’s completely legal to fire someone for any reason in more states than those where it’s legal to fire someone for being gay.

The fact that the mainstream gay and lesbian movement has been able to use and reuse the first statistic without anyone really questioning them on the second fact speaks volumes about labor laws in the US. In the long run, ENDA will do little more than provide cover for larger companies and corporations who already espouse “gay-friendly” policies, while doing nothing at all to improve labor relations and ensure stable and well-paid employment for all.

429Magazine

Yasmin Nair lives and works in Chicago. Visit her website here.

Comments
over 2 years ago

Bravo Yasmin Nair for broadening the discussion to workplace practices, dress codes, labor relations, job stability and good pay, and so many other interrelated issues that are meaning for all of us, not just mainstream gays and lesbians.

Comment by sirking79
30 days ago

I am definitely enjoying your website. You definitely have some great insight and great stories. free instagram followers | free instagram likes

29 days ago

The act provides basic protections against discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity in employment, access to public spaces, housing. On September 23, the House Education and Labor Committee conducted a hearing on ENDA, which now has the bipartisan support of 178 members of the House of Representatives. http://mcxbulliontips.in/

Comment by japancomp
23 days ago

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. how to get instagram followers and likes

Comment by sirking79
21 days ago

I am very much pleased with the contents you have mentioned. I wanted to thank you for this great article. instagram auto followers | how to get likes on instagram fast

Comment by sirking79
16 days ago

Very useful info. Hope to see more posts soon!. http://coolleggings.net

Comment by Founds
13 days ago

Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to more added agreeable from you! However, how can we communicate? followers for instagram

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

Seeing ads on social media is one of the top ways users of social media find out about new products, new brands, and new services. buy youtube likes and comments

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

This has a huge impact since the majority of adults in the United States are on social media. youtube video with most likes

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

If you are targeting a younger audience, the vast majority of them are on social media. get youtube likes

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

eMarketer, a world leader in research in the digital world, reports that between 20 and 25% of people who see a social media ad on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram buy youtube views and likes

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

Pinterest, will then respond by visiting the store or website on the ad. In addition, they reported that between 14 and 17% went ahead and bought a product or service. free youtube likes

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

If you do not have a comprehensive social media campaign, 2016 is the time to do it.If you give your social media followers exclusive deals and promotions youtube likes

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

you can develop a larger audience, gain more customers, and take a close measure of conversions. You can also inspire loyalty from these important customers. buy youtube likes

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

It is common for a business to try and get external audiences to generate a buzz about their products and services. how to increase more youtube views

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

You will find it is much cheaper and much easier to do than getting an external audience to generate product publicity. are buying youtube views safe

Comment by EstelaHale
11 days ago

More people trust this type of marketing, and brands including IBM have used this technique with great success. get 10 000 youtube views

Comment by japancomp
10 days ago

It was a decent post to be sure. I altogether delighted in understanding it in my lunch time. Will without a doubt come and visit this blog all the more regularly. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing. marc

Comment by japancomp
10 days ago

Pleasant to be going to your web journal once more, it has been months for me. Well this article i've been sat tight for so long. I require this article to finish my task in the school, and it has same theme with your article. Much appreciated, awesome offer. marc

Comment by PatricaBlake
9 days ago

You could definitely see your enthusiasm within the work you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe. Always go after your heart. real instagram followers buy get instagram followers cheap

Comment by PatricaBlake
9 days ago

I have read some excellent stuff here. Certainly worth bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how much effort you place to create any such great informative web site. secret to getting followers on instagram how can i get followers fast on instagram

Comment by PatricaBlake
9 days ago

Aw, this was an exceptionally nice post. Taking a few minutes and actual effort to create a great article… but what can I say… I hesitate a lot and don’t seem to get anything done. get more instagram followers fast free how to buy followers on instagram cheap

Comment by PatricaBlake
9 days ago

Hi, i think that i saw you visited my website thus i came to “return the favor”.I’m attempting to find things to enhance my web site!I suppose its ok to use a few of your ideas!! how to buy instagram followers free facebook likes for sale

Comment by PatricaBlake
9 days ago

Thank you for every ther informative site. Where else maay just I am getting that type of information written in such ann ideal manner? I have a undertaking that I’m simply now operating on, and I have been at the look out for such info. how to gain free instagram followers fast followers for free instagram

Comment by japancomp
4 days ago

I would like to say that this blog really convinced me to do it! Thanks, very good post. enziweb

Culture
Trend Report: Menswear FW16
Culture
For Dolce & Gabbana, fashion is remedy
Culture
Beyoncé's politcal Superbowl performance honors Black Lives Matter
Poll_balloon
Do you own your own business?
 
Yes
 
No
 
Trying to